Should You Remodel Your Existing Pool or Build New?

If you have an outdated or aging pool, you might be asking: Should I remodel what I have—or start from scratch with a new custom design? It’s a common question, especially for homeowners in established neighborhoods like Brentwood, Franklin, and Forest Hills.

The answer depends on your pool’s condition, your goals, and how far you want to take your outdoor space. Here’s how to evaluate the decision—and how Basin Pool Designs can help with either path.

1. When Remodeling Makes Sense

If your pool’s structure is solid and the footprint still fits your lifestyle, remodeling can give your space a new life without full reconstruction.

Signs you’re a good candidate for a remodel:

• Cracked or outdated plaster but intact shell

• Tile or coping that’s worn or dated

• Equipment that needs upgrading (pump, filter, lighting)

• Desire to refresh aesthetics without changing size or shape

Common remodel options include:

• New plaster, pebble, or quartz finishes

• Tile and coping replacement

• New decking or patio surfacing

• Adding automation or lighting upgrades

2. When It’s Time to Rebuild

Sometimes remodeling costs get close to new construction—especially if:

• The pool has structural issues (leaks, shell damage)

• The layout no longer serves your needs

• You want to significantly change the shape, size, or depth

• You’re expanding the surrounding outdoor living space

Rebuilding gives you the freedom to:

• Redesign from the ground up

• Regrade or reconfigure your yard

• Add features like spas, sun shelves, or fire elements

• Create a fully cohesive design with your home’s architecture

It’s the best path when you want lasting value and a truly modern result.

3. Budget Considerations

In Middle Tennessee, pool remodels typically start around $25,000–$50,000, depending on scope.

New custom gunite pools start closer to $100,000–$150,000, but include:

• Reinforced shell

• Full equipment package

• Modern design from day one

• Long-term warranties and lifespan

We’ll walk you through both options so you can make an informed choice based on both budget and vision.

4. Consider the Big Picture

This decision isn’t just about cost—it’s about how you’ll use your space in the years ahead. If your needs have changed, or your existing pool holds back the rest of your backyard plans, rebuilding may unlock more value than patchwork upgrades.

On the other hand, if your pool simply needs a facelift or a few enhancements, a remodel can be a cost-effective transformation.

Let’s Find the Right Path for You

At Basin Pool Designs, we specialize in both custom pool construction and thoughtful remodels. Whether you’re looking to modernize what you have or start fresh, we’ll help you weigh your options and make the best long-term decision for your home.

Ready to explore your options? Schedule a consultation today.